Intellectuals and SocietyThomas Sowell
Scholar Thomas Sowell describes the role of the intellectual class, of which he is by definition a part, in modern societies. Intellectuals, as described in Dr. Sowell's "Intellectuals and Society", form a class made up of those whose occupation it is to produce ideas. More specifically, in "Intellectuals and Society", Dr. Sowell says of Intellectuals, it is those whose work "begins and ends with ideas". Sowell differentiates between Intellectuals and a larger intelligentsia, of which the Intellectuals form the core. Surrounding the Intellectuals, the larger part of the intelligentsia is made of those who develop, disseminate, and advocate the ideas flowing from the core. Around the core, these sycophants gather from a variety of motivations, but basically analogous to moths gathering to a candle either seeking or blinded by the light. Nonetheless, this ring of sycophants provides the means by which the intellectual core of the intelligentsia exercises its power. It seems the intelligentsia's power in society began to expand rapidly at the dawn of the 20th Century when it began exercising greater direct influence on societal, particularly government, leaders. Indirectly, it advocated programs seeking to change cultural norms into compliance with its vision and to cultivate societal docility toward change contemporarily unacceptable. With the rapid expansion of communication technology over the last hundred years, the power of the intelligentsia has grown beyond influencing government leaders directly and society through steady but patient indoctrination. Using technology and proven techniques of persuasion the intelligentsia can now directly manipulate society at large, thus compelling its leaders to implement the Intellectuals' ideas and vision upon society. In short, there has been an unprecedented shift in power from leaders on the one hand and from the people on the other to this relatively small class of people defined as Intellectuals.
Thomas Sowell does not attack intelligence or a legitimate role for intellectuals in society. Rather he has identified historical events which show this power shift has resulted in disaster after disaster befalling humanity. Although citing multiple historical events to prove his contention, Thomas Sowell is particularly persuasive in his contention that the role of Intellectuals in shaping policy from World War I through the Great Depression led to the devastation of World War II. In particular, intellectual thought has consistently led to policies based on Intellectuals' ideals and myopia rather than realistic assessment of conditions, events, and patterns. The basic reason behind this is the limitation of human capability. In summary, there is just too much information for a small class of people, let alone any individual, to absorb and process. Additionally, implied although not directly stated in "Intellectuals and Society", it seems the closed nature of the intellectual class, its incestuous processing of ideas unabated by reality outside its circle, and the tendency for arrogance to attach to intelligence, drive out the humility that is prerequisite to wisdom. In fact, consistent and disastrous failure, like some strange sect on the morning after the promised ship failed to arrive, has only served to cement their vision and reinvest their ideas. The resulting pomposity of the intelligentsia has led to its disdain for the other classes of society. The intelligentsia sees itself as ascendant above society, and Intellectuals as above all. As a result, the intellectual class assumes the moral high ground in compelling our compliance with its vision - as it is, in their view, for our own good.
Thomas Sowell provides an alternative vision of society; one which compels society toward the best economic outcomes for its members. On the one hand, a small class of intellectuals makes decisions for its members. Regardless of the intellectual prowess of this class or its members, the task is daunting and consistently good decisions impossible. Essentially, the rise of the Intellectuals is another form of the age old struggle between the ruled and its rulers. Thomas Sowell takes the side of liberty; to minimize the power of the rulers and protect the freedoms of the ruled. Each individual is far more capable of making decisions in his or her own life than is some far off, class cocooned intellectual. Millions of free, individual choices, made with relatively detailed information about the circumstances at each point of decision, will result superior outcomes for society.
DriveAuthor: Daniel H. Pink
In "Drive", Daniel H. Pink explains "The Surprising Truth About What Motivates Us". In particular, he explains the human motivators identified by science and how organizational practices are normally in conflict with these scientific facts. Science related to human motivation has continued to develop on psychological ideas first developed by Abraham Maslow in the 1950's and made a foundation of modern managerial thought by Douglas McGregor in the 1960's. "Drive" brings us up to date on the science of human motivation and how it should be applied to organizations.
Daniel Pink's "Drive" seems especially relevant to answering the perplexing question first identified and asked by Peter Drucker in the 1960's - how to motivate the knowledge worker. Knowledge workers are now economically predominant, and their performance is critical to most organizations. "Drive" provides the answers necessary to maximize performance of these workers. Interestingly, according to Daniel Pink, one of the main human motivators is mastery, a concept intensely discussed and developed by Peter M. Senge in "The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization". The ideas developed in Daniel Pink's "Drive" are consistent with those proposed by the best and most influential business thinkers of the last half century. Pink's contribution is in gathering the current scientific understanding on this subject and presenting it in a focused, easy read. "Drive" is thought-provoking and designed to help the reader generate ideas to apply their newly acquired knowledge to their particular managerial challenges.